Reason: Access restricted by the author. A copy can be requested for private research and study by contacting your institution's library service. This copy cannot be republished
What do Hong Kong adult primary care patients want from their general practitioners? Are they satisfied?
thesis
posted on 2017-02-17, 00:04authored byTse, Ivan Cheong Yau
Objective. Fulfillment of patients' expectations influences satisfaction, which in tum
affects treatment compliance and clinical outcome. Although there have been
regular research studies on patients' expectations and satisfactions in Western
countries, these concepts are relatively new in Hong Kong. This study aimed to
examine the relationships between adult primary care patients' expectations, what
they actually receive from the general practitioner, and their satisfactions with the
consultation.
Study Design. The methodology developed by William et al. was used in the Hong
Kong primary health care setting. The three standardized questionnaires, namely the
Patient Intentions Questionnaire (PIQ), the Expectations Met Questionnaire (EMQ),
and the Medical Interview Satisfaction Scale (MISS), were translated into Chinese
and tested for their reliability. Six private practice primary care physicians from
various districts were asked to recruit patients. Every third adult patient over 18
years of age coming to the practice during a 7-day period was invited to participate in
the study. They were asked to complete the questionnaires and take part in a follow
up interview. Principle component analysis was used to determine the groupings
(factors) of patient expectations. Subjects were divided into three approximately
equal-sized groups according to the number of expectations met, and one-way
A NOVA was carried out using the satisfaction index of MISS-21 as the independent
variable. Linear regression model was also used to analyze the relationship between
the different groups of expectations met and the satisfaction index.
Results. Translating the English versions of the questionnaires into Chinese and then
back into English did not significantly alter the meaning of the questionnaire items.
Kappa statistic demonstrated that the Chinese versions of standardized questionnaires
have high reliability with substantial to almost perfect agreement when they were
re-administered. 350 patients were invited to participate in the study, thirteen of
them declined, and fifteen questionnaires were not usable, giving a response rate of
92%. Principle component analysis revealed that "Emotional support" was
considered to be the most important factor by the patients. The results also
demonstrated that meeting patients' expectations is significantly associated with
higher rates of satisfaction.
Conclusions. This study translated and validated the Chinese versions of PIQ, EMQ,
and MISS-21. The most important reported expectations were the ''Emotional support" items, and the least important were the "Information seeking and
management" items. Patients with more expectations met were found to have
significantly higher scores on the satisfaction index.