Restricted Access
Reason: Access restricted by the author. A copy can be requested for private research and study by contacting your institution's library service. This copy cannot be republished
Cognitive Behaviour Therapy to Treat Sleep Disturbance and Fatigue Following Acquired Brain Injury
thesis
posted on 2017-04-10, 00:33 authored by Sylvia NguyenSleep disturbance and fatigue are common phenomena following
acquired brain injury (ABI). Prevention and management of these symptoms are important targets
in rehabilitation yet there is limited empirical investigation into effective
interventions. Although local, consensus-based guidelines have been put forward, there are no
universally established, evidence-based guidelines to treat poor sleep and fatigue
following traumatic brain injury (TBI) or stroke. Sleep disturbance and fatigue are inter-related
and have bidirectional relationships with cognitive deficits, depression, anxiety and pain. Cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) is a promising treatment given its success in treating
these symptoms in non-neurological populations. A small number of studies have
implemented CBT to treat insomnia and fatigue in ABI cohorts but further research is needed
to draw stronger conclusions regarding treatment efficacy.
The primary aims of the current research were to conduct a pilot randomised controlled trial (RCT) to 1) evaluate the effectiveness of an adapted CBT intervention for sleep disturbance and fatigue in a TBI sample, 2) investigate the efficacy of the same CBT intervention in a stroke sample and 3) identify predictors of positive response to CBT for sleep in both TBI and stroke participants.
Eligible participants (n=36) with history of mild to severe TBI or stroke with clinically significant fatigue and/or sleep complaints completed baseline assessment and were randomly allocated to intervention (CBT) or treatment as usual (TAU). The intervention consisted of eight weekly therapy sessions with a neuropsychologist. CBT was delivered according to a manualised protocol and adapted to accommodate cognitive impairments. Participants were reassessed at two months (post-therapy) and four months from baseline (two-month follow-up) on primary outcome measures: the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) and the Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS). Secondary measures assessed insomnia severity, daily fatigue levels, daytime sleepiness, mood and quality of life.
The first study with a TBI sample revealed significantly greater improvements for CBT recipients on the primary measure of sleep quality (PSQI) and in insomnia (Insomnia Severity Index) than TAU. While there was no change on the primary fatigue measure (FSS), daily fatigue levels (Brief Fatigue Inventory) were reduced following CBT. Secondary improvements were also noted in depression (Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale). Gains were maintained at two-month follow-up with large treatment effects by the end of the study.
In the second study with a stroke cohort, there was a significant reduction on the primary fatigue measure (FSS) following CBT. Improvements in sleep quality and insomnia were significant post-treatment but were attenuated at follow-up. CBT participants further reported significant decline in depression and increased physical quality of life (SF-36). Treatment gains were maintained up to two months after therapy cessation with large effect sizes.
The third study examined characteristics of treatment responders using classification and regression tree (CART) analyses. As a combined ABI sample, better memory, younger age and higher baseline depression were associated with greater improvements in sleep quality following CBT.
This research illustrates the feasibility of delivering adapted CBT to treat sleep disturbance and fatigue following ABI, but larger RCTs are required to extend and replicate these pilot findings.
The primary aims of the current research were to conduct a pilot randomised controlled trial (RCT) to 1) evaluate the effectiveness of an adapted CBT intervention for sleep disturbance and fatigue in a TBI sample, 2) investigate the efficacy of the same CBT intervention in a stroke sample and 3) identify predictors of positive response to CBT for sleep in both TBI and stroke participants.
Eligible participants (n=36) with history of mild to severe TBI or stroke with clinically significant fatigue and/or sleep complaints completed baseline assessment and were randomly allocated to intervention (CBT) or treatment as usual (TAU). The intervention consisted of eight weekly therapy sessions with a neuropsychologist. CBT was delivered according to a manualised protocol and adapted to accommodate cognitive impairments. Participants were reassessed at two months (post-therapy) and four months from baseline (two-month follow-up) on primary outcome measures: the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) and the Fatigue Severity Scale (FSS). Secondary measures assessed insomnia severity, daily fatigue levels, daytime sleepiness, mood and quality of life.
The first study with a TBI sample revealed significantly greater improvements for CBT recipients on the primary measure of sleep quality (PSQI) and in insomnia (Insomnia Severity Index) than TAU. While there was no change on the primary fatigue measure (FSS), daily fatigue levels (Brief Fatigue Inventory) were reduced following CBT. Secondary improvements were also noted in depression (Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale). Gains were maintained at two-month follow-up with large treatment effects by the end of the study.
In the second study with a stroke cohort, there was a significant reduction on the primary fatigue measure (FSS) following CBT. Improvements in sleep quality and insomnia were significant post-treatment but were attenuated at follow-up. CBT participants further reported significant decline in depression and increased physical quality of life (SF-36). Treatment gains were maintained up to two months after therapy cessation with large effect sizes.
The third study examined characteristics of treatment responders using classification and regression tree (CART) analyses. As a combined ABI sample, better memory, younger age and higher baseline depression were associated with greater improvements in sleep quality following CBT.
This research illustrates the feasibility of delivering adapted CBT to treat sleep disturbance and fatigue following ABI, but larger RCTs are required to extend and replicate these pilot findings.
