posted on 2017-01-12, 05:41authored byAnna Kristina Chapman
China has the
largest number of type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) cases globally and hence has
a pressing need for effective management strategies. Evidence-based guidelines
recognise the importance of a structured and systematic approach to the
management of T2DM that incorporates psychological care within clinical
recommendations. However, psychological care is a relatively new field in China
and the utilisation and effectiveness of this aspect of care is relatively
unknown. As such, this thesis sought to examine the effectiveness of
psychological interventions for the management of T2DM in China. Two research
studies were designed and executed in order to meet this aim.
The systematic review and meta-analyses presented in Study
One was the first to assess the effectiveness of psychological interventions in
improving T2DM-related outcomes in China. The findings obtained supported the
use of psychological therapies, namely cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT),
motivational interviewing (MI), and client-centred therapy for the improvement
of glycaemic and psychological outcomes of T2DM. However, only three studies
were found that could be included in the meta-analysis for MI; the
methodological quality of the majority of included studies was debatable; and
only three studies (one utilising CBT; two utilising MI) were conducted within the
community health setting. These notable limitations consequently limited the
generalisability and statistical power of findings obtained in Study One.
The lack of methodologically robust studies utilising MI
within the community health setting consequently led to Study Two – the first
large-scale pragmatic cluster randomised controlled trial of a T2DM management
intervention that utilised health coaches trained in MI within community health
stations in urban China. The findings obtained from this study opposed those
that were obtained from the meta-analyses of Study One; no differential
treatment effects were observed for glycated haemoglobin or the majority of
secondary physiological, psychological and self-care outcomes.
The overall findings obtained within this thesis indicate
that it may be premature to recommend the routine delivery of psychological
interventions (in particular, MI) for the management of T2DM in China.
Additional high-quality, large-scale research is required that is conducted and
reported according to recognised frameworks, such as the CONSORT statement.
This will allow international standards to be met, will enable adequate risk of
bias assessments to be performed, and will increase the rigor of future
reviews.
The two studies comprised within this thesis represent a
foundational step toward the implementation of rigorously designed
psychological interventions in China, specifically targeting T2DM. Given the
combination of China’s increasing burden of T2DM and the governments’ strong
commitment to healthcare reform, the opportunities for meaningful contributions
in the field of chronic disease management in China are manifest. The Chinese
government and Chinese Medical Association are striving to adopt best practice
medical management and the continued examination of the effectiveness of
psychological interventions in T2DM management is a worthy and important
element.